In Her Own Words
(Left to right) Nadera Hayat Borhani, Sarbani Ghosh Laskar and Miriam Joy Calaguas.
Doctors working in Afghanistan, the Philippines and India speak about the cancer situation in their countries. They spoke to Kirstie Hansen during the IAEA Nobel Fund "Special Event" in Bangkok. The IAEA is expanding its current efforts to make more cancer centres operational and train the doctors and needed staff in countries most in need.
Nadera Hayat Borhani: Afghanistan
In Afghanistan Dr. Nadera Hayat Borhani worked during the former Taliban rule. She was one of the few doctors able to treat women. Dr. Borhani travelled by special car to the houses of female patients forbidden to leave their homes. Today she is the Afghan Deputy Minister of Public Health.
"Nobody in Afghanistan has access to health facilities for cancer. It´s the same situation for the children, the men, the women, the elderly - nobody has access. Thirty years ago we had a centre for radiotherapy and a centre for diagnosis. But unfortunately during the war everything was destroyed and the infrastructure, the equipment, everything, was destroyed. So nearly we are starting at zero again".
"When the doctor sees some sign or symptom that a patient has cancer – the option is to send the patient to Iran, or to go to Pakistan, or to India, as their economic situation allows. But Afghanistan has a low economic situation, and most of the people are very poor, so most of them don´t go".
"I also worked in a provincial hospital for 15 years, so I met many patients with cancer but unfortunately we cannot help them. In my heart I want to work with my people - especially for the women and children. All over the world they are the most vulnerable, but especially in Afghanistan. As you know we were suffering during the war from bad culture, it´s not religious culture, but it´s a bad culture of war. Always women are under pressure: they don´t have the right to go to a health facility in rural areas without permission of the mother-in-law or father-in-law or husband. It´s changing day-by-day but unfortunately if the families don´t accept it, it´s difficult, so we need time to change our people. We want to educate them, to teach them that this is a woman´s right, a child´s right, a human right. For this change, it will take years and years".
"In 2002 the coverage of health services was 9% in Afghanistan. But fortunately this access now reached 82% but only for basic health services. For an essential package of hospital services it´s about 28% - 30% coverage. But there is no radiotherapy for cancer".
"A big problem we face in Afghanistan is lack of skilled female health staff. Literacy is low among women, about 15%. Afghanistan is a mountain country and mostly the people who are living in very rural areas don´t access water, electricity, transportation, roads, so it´s hard to access schools and hospitals. Doctors don´t want to go to rural areas and women from rural areas can not go to the city for training unless their whole family agrees and moves with them. So far we are finding it very difficult to recruit women specialists for training".
"We need a cancer registry in Afghanistan to see the numbers and different types of cancers in the country. Sadly in Afghanistan we do not know this. We need this information to make our policy. We have some data from the paediatric hospital in Kabul. They now have about 75 children with leukaemia. But the real number I think is much greater, because the doctors send cancer patients to the foreign countries for treatment, or home to die. Even in my family I have a history of cancer. My uncle and aunt had cancer of the brain. We need a cancer treatment centre in Afghanistan, and to have radiotherapy treatment."
Through its technical cooperation programme the IAEA is supporting the establishment of radiotherapy capabilities in Kabul for the treatment of cancer patients in Afghanistan. Over $4 million has been allocated to support the establishment of a radiation oncology centre in the Medical University of Kabul, over the next seven years.
Miriam Joy Calaguas: The Philippines
Miriam Joy Calaguas works in two worlds. The Filipino radiation oncologist treats cancer patients with state-of-the art radiotherapy treatment at a private clinic in Manila. But on Wednesdays and Thursdays, she leaves the pristine corridors of St Luke´s Private Hospital, to work at the two main public hospitals in the city.
"I have the privilege to work at the premier hospital where cancer patients - who can afford it - get the best in radiation treatment. At the same time, I see what is going on in the government hospitals – the lack of facilities, the lack of equipment and manpower. Where patients line up to get a slot, sometimes waiting two to three months. By the time their turn for radiation treatment comes, the tumor has already grown so big or even spread. So our treatment strategy is totally different in the public hospital. We select patients with an early diagnosis and give them priority over the ones whose cancer already has advanced to late stages."
"You feel hopeless sometimes. You don´t offer them the treatment because you know they can not afford it. It´s bad enough already knowing that they are stuck with a terminal illness, without knowing that there is another kind of treatment that can extend their life but they cannot afford it. You have to be aware of the sensitivities."
"In the public hospitals we have only one machine, with about 100 patients to treat. It is used until 2am in the morning. The technicians are overworked and underpaid, unlike in the private hospital, where they pay overtime."
"It´s frustrating because you know what to do, but there are just not the resources. The Government doesn´t have the money for a cancer control programme; sadly health is not really in the top priorities. So we need outside donors like PACT. We have the people. We have trained staff in the Philippines who are capable and smart, that we train here at the University. But what can you do without the facilities and radiotherapy equipment? You cannot treat with your hands."
Cancer is the third biggest killer in the Philippines. It is estimated that one of every 1000 Filipino will get cancer. In a county of 66 million people spread over more than 7 000 islands, only a small sector of Filipino society has access to advanced technology that can treat cancer.
Sarbani Ghosh Laskar: India
In India, Dr. Sarbani Ghosh Laskar is one of 14 radiation oncologists working at the Tata Memorial hospital in Mumbai. The hospital registers about 25, 000 new cases of cancer each year, of which 75% are in advanced stages.
"We have a huge load of patients; we treat about 450 cases every day, with our radiotherapy facilities. It would seem to the onlooker that we´d go mad with the numbers but it´s not frustrating because we do cure patients. The only frustrating thing is that patients do have to wait because the numbers are so huge. We treat about 60% of our patients for free."
"Of the patients we see each year, about 14,000 are in advanced stages of disease, some 30% are suitable for treatment, the remaining for palliation. We see about 5,000 head and neck cancers a year, and a similar number of cervical cancers."
"India is a very big country and you´ll find a lot of disparity in the resources you have across the country. Luckily for us we are a tertiary hospital supported by the Department of Atomic Energy, so as far as resources go, we aren´t too strained. We´ve got everything that you can ask for in terms of equipment – three cobalt units, three linier accelerators a brachytherapy unit - but even so, it´s less than the numbers you have to deal with."
"When cancer strikes women, it hits the family hard. The woman is not only the care giver in the family; she also is the breadwinner a lot of the times. Even in the rural setups. The patterns of cancer are very different in the city to the rural areas in India. In the metropolis like Bombay that´s where you have breast cancers, whereas in the rural areas uterine and cervical cancers are more common. In the rural areas women are often not aware of screening programmes, and multiple childbirths are common. Women are often a little shy to report to you, so won´t show until they have advanced stages of cancer. There are still people who ask us if cancer is communicable."
The Tata Memorial hospital where Dr. Laskar works has adopted inventive ways to help women detect cancer early. The country cannot afford a pap-smear programme. So primary health care workers rely on their resourcefulness instead. They visit the cities slums to screen women for cervical cancer using makeshift lamps and conduct a visual inspection. This cheap method is making a real dent in detecting cancers earlier, when the disease is treatable and curable.
The IAEA, through PACT, supports the establishment of Regional Cancer Control Training Networks around the world. The Tata Memorial Centre will be integral to this model, with India well placed to be a leader in training cancer professionals from other developing nations.